Quarterly Publication

The Main Policies of International Oil Companies (IOCs) in Petroleum Contracts: An Overview on Risk Service Contracts in Iran’s Upstream Oil Industry

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Professor, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran

2 Ph.D. Student, University of Shahid Beheshti, Tehran, Iran

Abstract
Host countries invite international oil companies (IOCs) to conduct petroleum operations because the industry is naturally high cost, high risk and long term. Most governments don’t wish to risk its own capital and are better off avoiding the significant costs, risks and uncertainties associated with petroleum operations. In business relationships in the oil industry, IOCs enjoy high degree of technologies, skills and enough capitals often not available to the host countries and they are better poisoned to implement operations and take the risks if their policies are great achieved. IOCs follow their own policies and seek to obtain the most commercial and legal advantages such as reserve booking, high percentage of rate of return, assignment of their contractual rights and obligations, independent governing laws and dispute settlement and good governance on the project structure. The main objective of this article is to enumerate the key golden rules which IOCs are looking for in their business with the host countries or the NOCs and we are going to figure out to what extent IOC’s rules are satisfied in Iran's service contracts (buy-back and IPC).

According to our findings, although new Iran’s Petroleum Contract so-called IPC improves the buy-back’s terms and structure, for example, the remuneration for production is now on a per barrel basis, there are numerous weaknesses and other features that put IPC and buy-backs, as the risk service contracts, into the last IOC’s preference among other contractual regimes in the world.

Keywords

Subjects

A Brexendorff, Christian Ule and Maximilian Kuhn.(2009).The Iranian Buy-back Approach, Oil, Gas 
and Energy Law. 
A.A.E. Al-Attar and O. Alomair.(2005).The Relationship Between Upstream Petroleum Agreements 
and Exploration and Production Costs. 3 (2). 
A.F.M. Maniruzzaman. (2008). The Pursuit of Stability in International Energy Investment Contracts: 
A Critical Appraisal of the Emerging Trends. Journal of World Energy Law and Business. 1( 2), 
119–155.
Abba Kolo and Thomas Walde. (2003). Renegotiation and Contract Adaptation in the International 
Investment Projects: Applicable Legal Principles and Industry Practices. OGEL1(2).
Adrian Creed and Amir Kordvani. (2014). Iran’s new Integrated Petroleum Contracts, MENA, Legal 
Update, Clyde & Co., LLP. 
Bayuasi Nammei Luki and Nusrat-Jahan Abubakar. (2016). Dispute Settlement in the Oil and Gas 
Industry: Why is International Arbitration Important? Ghana Technology University College, P.O 
Box MC 3262, Takoradi W/R, Ghana, Journal of Energy Technologies and Policy.6(4), 30–38. 
Bahmani, M. A. and Afshar, E. / The Main Policies of International Oil Companies (IOCs) in … 101
Bernard Taverne. (1996). Product Sharing Agreements in Principle and in Practice in Martyn R David 
(ed), Upstream Oil and Gas Agreements: With Precedents (Sweet and Maxwell). 
Blinn, K., Duval, C., Leuch, H., and Pertuzio. (1986). A, International Petroleum Exploration and 
Exploitation Agreements. USA, Barrows Company 
Christopher B Strong. (2019). Oil and gas exploration and production in Iraq, Vinson and Elkins LLP. 
Daniel Johnston. (1994). International Petroleum Fiscal Systems and Production Sharing Contracts 
(PennWell Publishing Company).
E Smith, J Dzienkowski, O Anderson, J Lowe, B Kramer, and J Weaver. (2010). International 
Petroleum Transactions. (3rd ed., Rock Mountain Mineral Law Foundation).
Eduardo G. Pereira Tuuli Timonen Elina Aleynikova. (2022). Governing Law and Dispute Resolution 
in the Oil and Gas Industry, Part I: Key Principles and Issues Related to Governing Law and 
Dispute Resolution in the Oil And Gas Industry edited by Published by Edward Elgar Publishing 
Limited, the Lypiatts 15 Lansdown Road Cheltenham Glos GL50 2JA UK Edward Elgar 
Publishing, Inc. William Pratt House 9 Dewey Court Northampton Massachusetts 01060 USA.
Ernest E Smith.(1992) ‘From Concessions to Service Contracts’, Tulsa, 27(4), 493–524.
Gilles LHUILIER. (2015). The Drawing Up of International Extractive Contracts (OIL, GAS, 
MINING), 2015 Int'l Bus. L.J. 335 (2015).
Gray, C and Kingsbury, B. (1992). Developments in Dispute Settlement: inter-state arbitration since 
1945, reprinted from the British year Book of International Law., 63 (1), 97–134.
International Monetary Fund Petroleum fiscal regimes, retrieved from 
https://www.elibrary.imf.org/display/book/9780415781381/ch004.xml.
International Monetary Fund. (2010). Edited by Philip Daniel, Michael Keen and Charles McPherson, 
The Taxation of Petroleum and Minerals Principles, problems and practice, first published 2010 
by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Simultaneously published 
in the USA and Canada by Routledge 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, This edition 
published in the Taylor and Francis e-Library, © 2010.
International Monetary Fund. (2010). Petroleum fiscal regimes, Routledge.
James Dallas and partners. (2016). New Model Iranian Petroleum Contract, Oil and Gas, lexology, 
www.dentons.com/en/insights.
Jubilee Easo. (2009). A Practical handbook, Oil and Gas, Production Sharing Agreements and Service 
Contracts, Consulting editor Jeoffrey Picton Turbervill, Ashurst LLP. 
Keith Myers and Glada Lahn Edited by Valerie Marcel, John Mitchell and Willy Olsen, Chatham House 
and the Centre for Energy. (2006). Petroleum and Mineral Law Policy (CEPMLP), GOOD 
GOVERNANCE OF THE NATIONAL PETROLEUM SECTOR – INTERIM REPORT., 
Sponsored by some giant IOCs named at Shell, BP, Statoil, ExxonMobil Corporation, Petrobras 
and also by International Petroleum Industry Environmental Conservation Association (IPIECA). 
Kirsten Bindermann. (1999). Production-Sharing Agreements: An Economic Analysis, Oxford Institute 
for Energy Studies, WPM 25, Volume 25 of WPM (Oxford Institute for Energy Studies)., 93 
pages.
102 Petroleum Business Review, Vol. 8 (2024), No. 2
Lawrence W. Newman and Richard D. Hill. (2014). International Arbitration in Oil, Gas and Energy, 
The Leading Arbitrator’s Guide to International Arbitration in Lawrence W Newman (ed.). ISBN:
978-1-937518-33-2., 1,200 pages.
M Bunter. (2009). The Iranian Buy Back Agreement, Oil, Gas and Energy Law.
Mark Hammerson. (2011). Upstream Oil and Gas: Cases, Material and Commentary (1st edn, Globe 
Law and Business)., 589 pages, ISBN: 9781905783472.
Michael Polkinghorne and Courtney Kirkman. (2011). Choice of Law in Oil and Gas Agreements: It 
Does Make a Difference. 9(1) OGEL.
Mohsim.SH.Salih and Rdhwan.SH.Salih (2017). Legal Protection for Confidential Information in 
International Oil and Gas Contracts, Journal of college of Law for Legal and Political Sciences., 
6(21)., 382–419.
Nima Nasrollahi Shahri. (2010). The Petroleum Legal Framework of Iran: History, Trends and the Way 
Forward’, China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, 8( 1)., p111., Academic Journal. 
P D Cameron and Michael C. Stanley. (2017). Oil, Gas, and Mining: A Sourcebook for Understanding 
the Extractive Industries. (World Bank Group, Washington)., https://doi.org/10.1596/978-0-
8213-9658-2, 332 pages. 
Paul Michael Blyschak. (2010). Arbitrating Overseas Oil and Gas Disputes: Breaches of Contract 
Versus Breaches of Treaty. Journal of International Arbitration., 27 (6). 579 – 629. 
Pedro van Meurs. (2009). Commentary on the Iraq Draft Technical Service Contract., OGEL.
Peter D Cameron. (2013). International Energy Investment Law: The Pursuit of Stability. (OUP) 1.
Peter Roberts. (First Edition, 2016), Oil and Gas Contracts: Principles and Practice.
Philip Daniel, Michael Keen and Charles McPherson. (2010).The Taxation of Petroleum and Minerals 
Principles, problems and practice. Edited by, © 2010 International Monetary Fund, ISBN 0-203-
85108-0 Master e-book ISBN. 
Piero Bernardini. (2008). Stabilization and adaptation in oil and gas investments, Journal of World 
Energy Law and Business, 1( 1)., Oxford University Press.
Ratko Brnabic. (2016). Production Sharing Contracts in the Oil and Gas Industry. Faculty of Law in 
Split, Croatia rbrnabic @pravst. Hr. 
Rdhwan Shareef Salih and Professor Dr. Akram Yamulki. (2020). Petroleum Exploration and 
Production Contracts as Regulatory Tools: The Kurdistan Region Production Sharing Contracts. 
Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization., Vol 101. 
Rebecca Williams and Mark Mcallister-Jones. (2020). Assignment and Novation: Spot the Difference. 
Watson Farley and Williams.
Richard Mallinson. (2017). the IPC terms demonstrate a Big Improvement on Iran’s Old Oil Contract 
Model’, An interview made by Kourosh Ziabari.
Richard Parris and Louis Skyner. (2017). Key comparisons of the new Iran Petroleum Contract and 
Buy-back, Cliffordchance.
Roland Brown. (1976). Choice of Law Provisions in Concession and Related Contracts, The Modern 
Law Review. Published by Wiley., 39(6)., pp. 625–643. 
Bahmani, M. A. and Afshar, E. / The Main Policies of International Oil Companies (IOCs) in … 103
Salman Mahmood and Michael Earley, Sultan Al-Abdulla and Partners. (2019). Oil and gas regulation 
in Qatar: overview. © 2023 Thomson Reuters, Resource Type Country Q&A, Jurisdiction. 
Simon Vorburger and Angelina M Petti. (2018). ‘Chapter 11: Arbitrating Energy Disputes’, in Manuel 
Arroyo (ed), Arbitration in Switzerland: The Practitioner’s Guide. (2nd edn, Kluwer Law 
International).
Stephanie Ngopouhe. (2019). the most appropriate upstream contract for developing countries. 
University of Dundee, p 1–20.
Vahan Zanoyan. (2005). Institutional Cooperation in Oil and gas: Governments, Companies and the 
Investment Climate, 35 (1), 27 p, OGEL. 
Willem JH Van Groenendaal and Mohammad Mazraati. (2006). A Critical Review of Iran’s Buy-back 
Contracts., 34(18), 3709–3718
Zhuo Feng, Shui-Bo Zhang and Ying Gao On. (2014). On Oil Investment and Production: A 
Comparison of Production Sharing Contracts and Buy-back Contracts. Volume 42 Energy 
Economics, 395–402

  • Receive Date 12 February 2024
  • Revise Date 12 April 2024
  • Accept Date 05 May 2024