Quarterly Publication

Document Type : Original Article


Petroleum University of Technology


The motivation of this paper is the way in which the alternative fuel modes for public transport are analyzed. The aim is proposing a hybrid method to select the best fuel for public transport. The buses with old and new alternative fuels are considered in this paper. Several types of fuels are considered as alternative-fuel modes, e.g., conventional diesel, ultra-low-sulfur diesel fuel, bio-diesel fuel, and electric and gasoline hybrid engine. Moreover, many decision criteria categorized into performance, environmental, economical, infrastructure, technological, social, and risk are taken into consideration. The paper uses a hybrid multi-criteria decision analysis model to rank the fuel modes and/or choose the most efficient one. This hybrid method consists of rank order centroid method to assign the weights to the criteria, and additive ratio assessment technique to analyze the decision-making matrix. To demonstrate the applicability and flexibility of the model, a case study with data given by the experts from the respected fields is employed. The result presents that the liquefied propane gas (LPG) outperforms the other options in terms of the selected criteria.


Ahn, B.S., and Park, K.S., (2008), Comparing methods for multiattribute decision making with ordinal weights Computers & Operations Research, 35: 1660–1670. Alfares, H.K., and Duffuaa, S.O., (2008), Assigning cardinal weights in multi-criteria decision making based on ordinal ranking, Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis, 15(5– 6):125–133. 
Barron, F., Barrett, B.E., 1996, Decision quality using ranked attribute weights, Management Science, 42(11): 1515-1523. 
Bauer, C.G., and T.W., Forest, (2001), Effect of hydrogen addition on the performance of methane-fueled vehicles. Part I: Effect on S.I. engine performance, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 26(1): 55-70. 
Bosshard, R., (2015), Multi-objective Optimization of Inductive Power Transfer Systems for EV Charging, PH.D Thesis, ETH Zurich. 
Brinkman, N.D., Galloupoulous. N.E., and Jackson M.W., (1975), Exhaust emissions, fuel economy, and drivability of vehicles fueled with alcohol–gasoline blends, SAE Paper, 750120. 
Dawes, R.M., Corrigan, B., 1974, Linear models in decision making, Psychological Bulletin, 81: 91-106. Farkas, A., (2013), A Comparison of MCDA Techniques TOPSIS and MAROM in Evaluating Bus Alternative-fuel Modes, 11thInternational Conference on Management, Enterprise and Benchmarking (MEB), Budapest, Hungary. Farkas, A., (2014), An Interaction-based Scenario and Evaluation of Alternative-Fuel Modes of Buses, Acta Polytechnica Hungarica, 11(1): 205-225. 
Fazal, M.A., Haseeb, A.S.M.A., Masiuki, H.H., (2011), Biodiesel feasibility study: An evaluation of material compatibility; performance; emission and engine durability, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 15: 1314–1324. 
Fisher, T.M., Farley, K.B., Gao, Y., Bai, H., and Tse, Z.T.S., (2014), Electric vehicle wireless charging technology: a stateof-the-art review of magnetic coupling systems, Wireless Power Transfer, 1(2): 87-96. 
Gifford, K., (2003), Advances in diesel engine technology, Clean Diesel Conference, Denver, Diesel Technology Forum. 
Gyetvay, M., (2012), Russian Natural Gas Frontiers, Developing the Yamal and Gydan Peninsulas, a Report Published in www. novatek.ru.
Hythane, (2007), Hythane - Blue Sky, Clean Air, www.hythane. com. 
IEA (International Energy Agency), (2011), Advanced Motor Fuels Annual Report, a Report Published in www.iea-amf.org. 
Lootsma, F.A., (1999), Multi-criteria Decision Analysis via Ratio and Difference Judgment, Springer, Berlin. Lozanovski, A., Whitehouse, N., Ko, N., and Whitehouse. S., (2018), Sustainability Assessment of Fuel Cell Buses in Public Transport, Sustainability, 10-1480: 1-15. 
Morita, K., (2003), Automotive power source in 21st century, Journal of Society of Automotive Engineers of Japan, 24: 3-7. 
Mousaei, A., and Hatefi, M.A., (2015), A Decision Support System (DSS) to select the premier fuel to develop in the value chain of natural gas, Journal of Oil & Gas Science and Technology, 4(3): 60-76. 
Nagalingam, B., Duebel, F., and Schmillen, K., (1983), Performance study using natural gas; hydrogen-supplemented natural gas and hydrogen in AVL research engine, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 8:715–720 
NPC (National Petroleum Council), (2012), Advancing Technology for America’s Transportation Future: Fuel and Vehicle System Analyses, a Report Published in http://www. npc.org. 
Nylund, N.O., and Koponen, K., (2012), Fuel and Technology Alternatives for Buses: Overall Energy Efficiency and Emission Performance, a Report Published in http://www. biofuelstp.eu. 
Omidvarborna, H., Ashok, K., and Dong-Shik, K, 2014, Characterization of particulate matter emitted from transit buses fueled with B20 in idle modes, Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering, 2(4): 2335–2342. Patil, A., and Herder, P., and Brown, K., (2010), Investment decision-making for alternative fuel public transport buses: The Case of Brisbane transport, Journal of Public Transportation, 13(2): 115-133. Patil, K.D., Pathan, F.U., Mahajan, S.M., and Satpute, D.R., (2014), Alternative Fuel Public Transport Buses, International Journal of Engineering Research and Development, 10(12): 29-35. 
Poh, K.L., and Ang, B.W., (1999), Transportation fuels and policy for Singapore: an AHP planning approach, Computers and Industrial Engineering, 37(4): 507–525. Raslavicius, L, Kersys, A., Mockus, S., Kersienc, N., and Starevicius, M. (2014), Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) as a medium-term option in the transition to sustainable fuels and transport, Renew Sustain Energy Review, 32: 513–525. 
Sajjad, H., Masjuki, H.H., Varman, M., Kalam, M.A., Arbab, M.I., Imtenen, S., and Rashed, M.M. (2014), Comparative study of gas-to-liquid fuel, B5 diesel and their blends with respect to fuel properties, engine performance and exhaust emissions, RSC Advances, 4: 44529-44536. 
Sclar, D., (2011), Auto Repair for Dummies, 2nd edition, Wiley.
Shah, M.S., Halder, P.K., Shamsuzzaman, A.S.M., Hossain, M.S., Pal, S.K., and Sarker, E., (2017), Perspectives of Biogas Conversion into Bio-CNG for Automobile Fuel in Bangladesh, Journal of Renewable Energy, 4385295: 1-14. 
Singh, A.P., Agarwal, R.A., Agarwal, A.K., Dhar, A., and Shukla, M.K., (2018), Prospects of Alternative Transportation Fuels, Springer. 
Sperling, D., 1995, Future-drive electric vehicles and sustainable transportation, Island Press, Washington D.C. Stillwell, W.G., Seaver, D.A., and Edwards, W., (1981), A comparison of weight approximation techniques in multiattribute utility decision making, Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 28(1): 62–77. 
The World LPG Association, (2010), Statistical Review of Global LP Gas. 
Tzeng, G.H., Lin, C.W. and Opricovic, S., (2005), Multi-criteria analysis of alternative fuel buses for public transportation, Energy Policy, 33: 1373-1383. Ulvestad, M., and Overland, I., (2012), Natural gas and CO2 price variation: Impact on the relative cost-efficiency of LNG and pipelines, International Journal of Environmental Studies, 69(3): 407–426. 
Uz, V., (2012), CNG as a Feasible Replacement for the U.S. Transportation Sector, M.S. Thesis, Air University, Captain. 
Vafaeipour, M., Hashemkhani Zolfani, S., Morshed Varzandeh, M.H., Derakhti, A., Keshavarz Eshkalag, M., (2014), Assessment of regions priority for implementation of solar projects in Iran: New application of a hybrid multicriteria decision making approach, Energy Conversion and Management, 86: 653-663. 
Vahdani, B., Zandieh, M., and Tavakkoli-Moghaddam, R., (2011), Two novel FMCDM methods for alternative-fuel buses selection, Applied Mathematical Modelling, 35: 1396- 1412. 
Winebrake, J.J., Creswick, B.P., (2003), The future of hydrogen fueling systems for transportation: an application of perspective-based scenario analysis using the analytic hierarchy process, Technology Forecasting Social Change, 70(2): 359–384. 
WSU, (2004), New engine technologies: Diesel emissions reports, Olympia, Washington, Washington State University, Energy Program. 
Yadav, B.K., Lal-Soni, S., Sharma, D., Sharma, P.K., (2017), Performance and emission analysis of constant speed SI engine operated on Hythane, International Journal of Science and Technology, 3(2): 64-79. Zavadskas, E.K., Turskis, A., Vilutiene, T., (2010), Multiple criteria analysis of foundation instalment alternatives by applying Additive Ratio Assessment (ARAS) method, Archives of civil and mechanical engineering, 3: 123-141. Zhang, J., and Markel, T., (2016), Charge Management Optimization for Future TOU Rates, World Electric Vehicle Journal, 8: 1-10