Quarterly Publication

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 PhD Candidate, Governmental Management, Islamic Azad University, Central Branch of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

2 Instructor, Governmental Management, Islamic Azad University, Central Branch of Tehran, Tehran, Iran

3 Deputy of Research and Technology Center; Islamic Azad University, Lamerd Branch, Iran, Email: ranjbarmokhta@yahoo.com

Abstract

The present research seeks to assess the relationship between the Individual value system and decision-making styles. The statistical population (190 people) consists of Pars Special Economic Energy Zone (PSEEZ) Organization managers who were assessed using the Census Method. The Myers and Myers cognitive demographic and value systems questionnaire and Scott and Bruce’s decision-making questionnaire were used with a response rate of 90%.. Data was analyzed with the SPSS and Smart Planning softwares. It was found that the dominant Individual value system is success-oriented, followed respectively by system-oriented, realistic, tribal, community-oriented, and autocentric.Also, the dominant decision-making style in the statistical population is rational, followed by intuitive, dependent, avoidant, and spontaneous decision-making styles respectively. It was also concluded that success-oriented and tribal value systems had the most significant relationship with decision-making styles and the community-oriented value system the least. Only the individual variables of race (ethnicity) and field of study had a significant relationship with the Individual value system. The other personal and organizational variables had no significant relationship with the Individual value system. Creating motivation and a sense of employee participation in the future of the organization is proposed as the most important way of improving the value system of the statistical population so that the tendency to make spontaneous decisions can lean more towards making rational decisions to the same extent. Investigating the relationship between decision-making styles is another effective topic in improving these in an organization and is thus recommended to other researchers in the field.

Keywords

Ali A.; Azim A.A. & Krishnan, K.S.; (1995). Expatriates and Host Country Nationals: Managerial Values and Decision Styles. Proceedings of Arab Management Group Conference. Bradford, England, July 4-7.
Ali, A. & Al-Shakhis, M; (1991). Changing Managerial Values in Saudi Arabia. Advances in International Comparative Management, Vol.6, P.81-102.
Ali, A. & Wahabi R.; (1995). Managerial Value Systems in Morocco. International Studies of Management and Organization. Vol. 25(3), P.87-97.
Ali, A.; (1982). An Empirical Investigation of Managerial Value Systems for Working in Iraq. Unpublished Doctoral thesis, West Virginia University
Amirshahi, MirAhammad; Mousavi, Shahrnaz & Tayyeb, Monir Alsadat; (2000). The Relationship between Culture and the Management of Human Resources, Tehran: Nakhl.
Amirshahi, Mirahmad; Milton-Smith, J. & Chatterjee S.; (1996). Public Sector Management Reform, the Case of Tehran Municipality, Iran. Proceedings of the 12th Academy of International Business: Southeast Asia Annual Meeting. Dunedin, New Zealand, June 17-20.
Amirshahi, Mirahmad;(1997). An empirical study of Managerial Value Systems and Decision-Making Styles Among the Managers in Iran, Doctoral thesis, Curtin University of Technology, Australia.
Arjomand-Kermani, Arash & Tirgar , Hedayat ; (2017) . Investigating the Correlation between Decision-Making Methods, Organizational Creativity and Information literacy in the Managers of Sarcheshmeh Copper Complex in Kerman, Bimonthly Journal of Applied Studies in Management and Development Sciences.
Barni, D.; Cavazza, N.; Russo, S.; Vieno, A. & Roccato M. ;(2020). Intergroup Contact and Prejudice toward Immigrants: A Multinational, multilevel test of the Moderating role of Individual Conservative Values and Cultural Embeddedness - International Journal of Intercultural Relations - Volume 75.
Cancer, S; (2020). BMC Psychology, Volume 8, Article Number: 11.
Corium, A. M.; (2015). Fuzzy Methods in Decision Making Process - A Particular Approach in Manufacturing Systems, IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering
Dabbaghi, Azadeh;(2017). Identification and Prioritization of the Organizational Capital Attributes in the Petroleum Industry in Iran Using Grey Systems Theory, Petroleum Business Review Journal, Volume 1, Issue 1, Pages 49-57.
Dreyer, R.S. ;(2014).  Decision-Making, NIOC Central Library.
Ebrahimi, Morteza; Eliki, Fahimeh& Mahram. Abbas ;(2017). Investigating the Effects of Talent Identification Management on Organizational Succession Planning, Noor Specialized Magazine, 43.
Elliott, B.L; Samuel M.; McClure; Gene, A. & Brewer; (2020). Individual Differences in Value-Directed Remembering - Cognition, Volume 201.
Faraz, Maryam; (2016).  Investigating the Effect of Succession Planning on Employee Performance Based on Balanced Scorecard and the Mediating Role of Commitment Variability.
Fischer, R.; Johannes & Karl, A. ;(2020). The network Architecture of Individual Differences: Personality, Reward-Sensitivity, and Values - Personality and Individual Differences - Volume 160, 1.
Flowers V.S., Hughes C.R., Myers M.S. & Myers S.S.; (1975). Managerial Values for Working. An AMA Survey Report. (New York: AMACOM).
Gambetti, E. & Giusberti F.; (2019). Personality, Decision-Making Styles and Investments - Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics - Volume 80.
Gavin, M.; (2020). 5 Key Decision-Making Techniques for Managers, Harvard Business School Online.
Graves C.W.; (1970). Levels of Existence: An Open System Theory of Values. Journal of Humanistic Psychology. Vol. X (2), P.131-54.
Kamakura, W.A. & Novak, T.P.; (1992). Value-system segmentation: Exploring the Meaning of LOV (list of values). Journal of Consumer Research. Vol. 19(1), P.ll9-33.
Kharazmi, Amir-Ali; Beigi-Nasrabadi, Fatemeh& Johari, Leila (2016). Analytical study of the Gap between the Current Situation and the Optimal Situation for Implementing Succession Management Plans in Mashhad City Council, Noor Specialized Magazine, Issue 27.
Khendum, C.; Kallol K., Bagchi; Godwin J.; Udo; Peeter J. & Kirs ;(2019). The influence of Individual Values on Internet use: A Multinational Study - International Journal of Information Management - Volume 46.
Krau, E.; (1987). The crystallisation of Work Values in Adolescence: a Sociocultural Approach. Journal of Vocational Behavior. Vol. 30(2), P.103-23.
Lăzărescu, M.; (2015). Personality Variables in Decision-Making, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 187.
Liat, E.; Alyssa, F.; Westring, S.D. & Friedman ; (2019) - The Indirect Effect of Holistic Career Values on Work Engagement: A Longitudinal Study Spanning Two Decades, Applied Psychology: Health and Well‐Being Volume 12, Issue 1 .
Linda N.; Douma; Ellen, U. &   Danielle, R. M.; (2020). Decision-Making Styles in the Context of Colorectal.
Moradi Zaniany, Davood & Amirhosseini,Syed Ehsan  ; (2016). Investigating the Relationship between the Process of Succession Planning and Organizational Maturity of Staff and Leadership Style of Managers in Kohgiluyeh and Boyer-Ahmad Province Gas Company Australian Journal of International Social Research, Volume: 02 Issue: 03 Pages: 1-13.
Mossop, C.; (1994). Value Assessment: key to Managing Careers. The Management Accounting Magazine. Vol. 68(2), P.33.
Murata, S.; Karana, H. & Cookson S. Semih; (2015). An Application for Measuring Performance Quality of Schools by Using the PROMETHEE Multi-Criteria Decision Making Method, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 195.
Myers, M.S. & Myers, S.S.; (1974). Toward Understanding the Changing Work Ethic. California Management Review. Vol. 16(3), P.7-19.
Norouzi, Nasrollah; Heidarpur, Elham & Sedaghat.  Kobra; (2015). Hierarchy of Values Among Preschool Teachers in Dashtestan. 2nd National Conference on Science, Educational Technology, Social Studies and Psychology in Iran.
Ohmoto, Y.; Kataoka, M.; Nishida, T.; (2013). Extended Methods to Dynamically Estimate Emphasizing Points for Group Decision-Making and their Evaluation, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 97.
Pishehgar, Akram & Kaveh, Mohammad Amin; (2016). Investigating the Relationship between the Value System and Job Performance of Lorestan Social Security Organization Employees, 2nd International Conference on Management and Information Technology.
Pour-MohammadShāhini, khashayar; (2011). Assessing Correlation of Individual Values with Managers' Decision Making Styles, Ahwaz Pipe Mill Company: A Case Study - Farabi Institute of Higher Education Graduate School of Management.
Pourtaheri, Mahdi; Pashanejad, Mahdi& Ahmadi, Ehsan ;(2016). Evaluating the Validity of Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Methods in Determining Appropriate Areas of Urban Development: Azarshahr Case Study, Noor Specialized Magazine, Issue 1, Vol. 20.
Radwan, E.; Rola, E.; Rabigh, H.; Sahar, O. & Souheil, H.; (2020). Personality Traits, Emotional Intelligence and Decision-Making Styles in Lebanese Universities Medical Students, BMC Psychology, Volume 8, Article Number: 46,2020.
Ralston, D.A.; Gustafson, D.J.; Cheung, F.M. & Terpstra, R.H.; (1993). Differences in Managerial Values: A Study of U.S., Hong Kong and PRC Managers. Journal of International Business Studies. Vol. 24(2), P.249-76.
Razavi, Seyyed Abdollah; Mohamadali, Tajrishi Iman; (2018). A Fuzzy Model for Measuring Organizational Strategy Alignment: A Case Study on South Pars Projects of Iran’s Oil Industry, Petroleum Business Review Journal, Volume 2, Issue 3 - Serial Number 4, Pages 47-55.
Rokeach, M.; (1973). The Nature of Human Values. (New York: Free Press).
Sagiv l. & Schwartz S. H.; (2007). Cultural Values in organisations: Insights for Europe. European J. International Management, Vol. 1, No. 3. School of Business Administration, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Schwartz, S.H. & Belsky, W.; (1987). Toward a Universal Psychological Structure of Human Value. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Vol. 53(3), P.550-62.
Shafiei-Haghshenas, Lida; (2016). Succession Management and Succession Planning Models, 3rd International Conference on Management, Economy and Development, 3.
Sorooshian, Shahryar; (2018).  Group Decision Making with Unbalanced-Expertise, Journal of Physics: Conf. Series 1028.
Tata, J.; (2011). National Cultural Values, Social Capital and Micro-Enterprise Success. Int. J. Business Environment, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2010, 95. School of Business Administration, Loyola University Chicago.
Valikhani, Mashallah; Hasehmi, Nadia & Nazeri, Mahmoud; (2014). Investigating the Relationship between Personal Value Systems and the Degree of Adherence to Ethical Behaviors in Organizations, 3rd Conference on Modern Management Sciences, 1151-2322.
Wahabi, R.; (1993). Values of Arab Executives: Case study of Morocco. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, Union Institute, Cincinnati, OH.
Yaghoubi, Sajjad & Yaghoubi, Mojtaba ;(2016). The Relationship between Value Systems and the Capabilities and Quality of Life of Special Middle School Principals in the Four Educational Districts of Shiraz Department of Education, Rome, Italy, 3rd International Conference on New Findings in Human Resources.